On April 5th 29 West Virginia miners died in an explosion at the Upper Big Branch Coal Mine owned by Massey Energy. Some of the families of the deceased have filed or plan to file wrongful death suits and NPR is reporting rumors that Massey has offered some of the families a 3 million dollar settlement. Regardless of lawsuits or settlements the families will receive the following death benefits:
- health insurance coverage for a period of 20 years (or life in some cases)
- life insurance payout five times the annual salary of the miner, which according to Massey's website averages $52,000 a year --> $52,000 * 5 = $260,000 lump sum insurance payout
- college tuition for children
- weekly paychecks until widows remarry (I haven't heard anything about common law marriages, civil unions, or same-sex partners, likely because it's irrelevant in this situation)
My Perspective:
Many people do not realize that coal mining is a prevalent industry in the United States. The West Virginia and Kentucky Mines that have been in the news represent only 2 of the 26 states in this country in which people are working in coal mines. The dangerous reality of this profession is not lost on many foreign countries where they don't have the comparable access to technological advances and the government regulation that make these accidents less frequent.
The reach and importance of coal mining extends far beyond that of a History Channel documentary. According to U.S. Energy Information Administration, "93% of coal in the U.S. is used for generating electricity". (Note that this is not the same as if they said coal from the U.S. since we both export and import coal, but that's getting off topic for this post) The energy industry is immense and highly profitable. Considering the benefits package and rumored settlement offered to the mine worker's families Massey Energy is looking at almost 90 million dollars in damage control. If and when a family accepts a settlement offer they would be releasing Massey Energy from all liability and giving up their right to follow through or file a wrongful death or any other suit related to the accident. A wrongful death suit with a ruling in favor of the mine worker's family could result in punitive damages, rather Massey would have to pay the families as punishment for negligence, action, or the failure to act on their part that contributed to the accident.
The fact that Massey can afford damage control that initially adds up to about 90 million dollars, not including public relations costs or the cost of controlling the ramifications of Massey's almost $14 dollar stock value decrease since the beginning of this month, is disconcerting. Looking at that dollar amount as the tip of the iceberg that's the coal industry's financial reserve, I'm left thinking about the dollar signs I can't see below the surface, money used to lobby Congress and further their own economic interests at the express of technological and environmental improvements, and wondering whether that money would be better spent elsewhere.
The fact that coal is a nonrenewable energy source, that 93% of coal in the U.S. is used to generate electricity, and that people risk their lives on a daily basis globally in order to procure coal from mines definitely makes me think twice about reducing my own energy consumption until the majority of energy use in the U.S. is produced by safe and renewable energy sources.
I'd love to see research data on deaths per energy unit for all energy sources.